Why He Wants to Start an Anti-Christmas Party

Paddy Sherman, Editor
The Vancouver Province (1970)

Frankly, I’m ready to give up Christmas. It has become so blatantly phony, so crassly commercial, so far in spirit from everything it is said to mean that each year it becomes more difficult for the romantic to rise above the cynic.
Such Christmas music. “Let Christmas light your happy heart, let G.E. light your tree.” Or, “Deck the boughs with Black & Decker.”
We need a new Dickens to snort ‘humbug’, a new Scrooge to tighten the fist on such disgusting distortions. We need an Anti-Christmas Party, and when I’m king I’ll start one.
It will have a number of simple rules:
  1. S. Clause, who somehow escaped prosecution by Mr. Basford although he is clearly guilty of the most misleading advertising, will be shot on sight if he appears before December 21. In fact, we’ll pay a handsome bounty on each set of long white whiskers.
  2. Ho-ho-horrible radio announcers will automatically lose their jobs if they start playing carols before December 21, or playing synthetic carols ever.
  3. Nobody will be allowed to spend more than $5.00 on a present for anybody. But everybody will be required to spend five hours thinking about the particular sort of gift that will suit a particular sort of person.
  4. Everyone who spends time, thought and affection making a gift for someone will get an income tax rebate.
  5. Everyone who declines to buy chocolates for their overfed family or new skis for the child whose last year's skis are better than the world champion used 10 years ago, but instead gives the money to those who need it, will get a medal.
The Anti-Christmas Party began to evolve, I suppose, almost 20 years ago. Doting grandparents had sent piles of presents for the first child, and there was some family debate which things to give him.
Because, after all, if the Christmas picture showed him hugging presents from Grandparents A, what would Grandparents B think?
So we carefully arranged them all under the Christmas tree then let him crawl through the open door. In he came, a little bewildered, eyed the piles of unfamiliar toys, then headed behind the nearest chair and picked up an empty beer bottle. Played with it for hours.
No, he didn't become a heavy drinker. But he took off in September, with less money than most families spend on Christmas presents, to see how the other half lives. He'll be in Morocco for Christmas. When he sees how that part of the other half lives, he'll probably be a charter member of my new anti-party when he comes back.
Most of the early members will be those who have visited the poorer countries, I expect. I've never been able to enjoy a wallowing Christmas since I've seen the poor in Hong Kong, on the back roads of Greece, or the devastated in Peru.
Or even the huge family in the Burns Lake country, years ago, that had triplets for Christmas, and wound up with about 16 people in one log cabin.
The way one little girl’s eyes grew wide in wonder when I gave her one doll will never fade from my mind.
Meantime, back under the Christmas commercial avalanche... It’s great for the economy, I suppose. Provides jobs for people who would otherwise have a lean time.
All this makes it easy to see what I want for Christmas. In a word, Christmas. Defining it is no easy task, and it’s easier to start with what it's not.
It’s not electronics screaming at me to buy more of everything to give to people who already have more than 90 percent of the rest of the world has.
It’s not spending a small fortune on elaborate greeting cards for people I may be able to make a better business deal with next year.
It’s not seeing children brainwashed with the idea that if they don't buy something that costs more money than they have, then they haven’t given a present of the sort society expects.
Nor is it putting up hundreds of dollars of coloured electric lights in November so that others can take a bus tour past your house to see that you spend more on this than the neighbours do.
It isn’t for me, even going to church on Christmas Day and taking part in a formal ritual.
And it certainly isn’t spending so much on presents for all that I have to go to the bank to pay the January bills.
It’s really a sell out from the whirl of life in which to sit down with family and friends and try to see what we’ve done and how we’re doing, in relation to the idea of Christianity and fellowship that started it all.
It’s best done in peace and quiet and honesty, which makes it very difficult.
For then we realize but how much farther we have to go before we give real meaning to all those glowing, glossy sentiments we so glibly sign on our Christmas cards.
Instead of a Merry Christmas, then, I’m going to wish you a quiet, thoughtful Christmas in which you let your thoughts roam freely, spurring you to do things you've meant to do for years but didn’t do.